Work place: M. Kh Dulati Taraz State University, Taraz, 080000, Kazakhstan
E-mail: makashkulova69@mail.ru
Website: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-2030-4351
Research Interests:
Biography
Gulzhan Makashkulova graduated from the Zhambyl Pedagogical Institute with a specialization in Preschool Pedagogy and Psychology. She obtained her Master’s degree in Psychology from M.Kh. Dulaty Taraz State University. She is the author of the educational textbooks Fundamentals of Psychology and Psychological Counseling, designed for students of the educational program in Pedagogy and Psychology. She is currently a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Pedagogical Psychology at M.Kh. Dulaty Taraz University. Her academic interests include pedagogical psychology, psychological counseling, professional training of future educators, and the development of psychological competencies in the educational process.
By Sultan Mukhamedaly Kymbat Kabekeyeva Gulnar Mussabekova Aliya Kuralbayeva Bagdat Toibekova Gulzhan Makashkulova Batyrkhan Omarov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5815/ijmecs.2026.02.01, Pub. Date: 8 Apr. 2026
This study proposes and empirically evaluates a pedagogical framework for ethical skill development in higher education within smart learning environments. The framework conceptualizes ethical competence as a multidimensional, process-oriented construct cultivated through authentic ethical scenarios, structured reflective cycles, adaptive learning support, and competence-aligned assessment. A quasi-experimental design was implemented with 90 undergraduate participants assigned to three groups: Group A (n = 30) learned using the framework with teacher guidance, Group B (n = 30) learned using the framework without teacher involvement, and Group C (n = 30) learned under traditional instruction without the framework. Ethical competence was measured via pre-test and post-test questionnaires capturing overall ethical skills and specific dimensions including ethical awareness, moral reasoning, reflective capacity, and ethical responsibility. Statistical analyses combined gain-score comparisons and covariate-adjusted models. Results indicate that the framework-based condition (Groups A+B) achieved significantly higher overall ethical skill development than the traditional condition, supported by large practical effects. Multivariate analysis further revealed significant framework-related advantages on the combined outcomes of ethical awareness and moral reasoning, with stronger effects observed for ethical awareness. Ethical responsibility also increased substantially under the framework relative to traditional instruction. Teacher guidance demonstrated a differentiated contribution: no significant difference emerged between Groups A and B in overall ethical skill development, whereas teacher-mediated scaffolding produced a significant and large improvement in reflective capacity compared to autonomous framework-based learning. These findings suggest that smart learning environments can support scalable ethical competence formation when pedagogical design integrates adaptive ethical tasks and structured reflection, while targeted instructor scaffolding remains important for deep reflective development. The study contributes actionable guidance for embedding ethics into smart education curricula and motivates future longitudinal and multi-institutional research using behavioral measures and discipline-specific adaptations.
[...] Read more.Subscribe to receive issue release notifications and newsletters from MECS Press journals